Collectors CornerSM: The Collectibles Marketplace

A Service of Certified Asset Exchange

Shopping Cart 0 item ($0.00)

(1834-37) $5 C. Bechtler, Carolina Gold MS62 PCGS

(click for full-size image)
Price: $44,500.00   
Grade: MS62
Quantity: 1
PCGS Coin #: 10091
Last Update: 11/9/2026
Dealer:  (Terms) AUCM (11)
Collector's Universe priced at $55,000. This well-struck, somewhat prooflike example of a Bechtler issue is a standout, graded at the highest level by PCGS, tied with only two other coins, one being a CAC example last seen 84 months ago. Light adjustment marks are visible at "CARATS" on the obverse and "? C." on the reverse, factored into its lofty grade by PCGS, with a population of just three and none finer. A critical piece for specialists, this coin is challenging to replicate at any price. Its historical significance is tied to the August 1, 1834, day date, reflecting Bechtler’s response to the Coinage Act of June 28, 1834, which altered gold coin composition and weight to encourage circulation. Prior to this, gold coins had vanished from domestic use since 1820 due to bullion values exceeding face values, forcing Bechtler and other coins to trade at a premium based on gold content.
Collectors CornerSM coin information:  (data courtesy of PCGS.com *)
PCGS Coin #: 10091
PCGS Coin Description: 1834 $5 C Bechtler, Rutherford Plain Edge
Mintage: n/a
Grade: MS62
PCGS Population: * 3 View
Population (in higher grades): * 0
PCGS Price Guide: * $55,000.00 View
Auction Prices Realized: * Auction Prices Realized
Additional resources: PCGS CoinFacts
PCGS Set Registry:
(Top 3 of 6 composite sets for this coin)
 
  Learn more about Set Registry
North Carolina Gold Type Set (Bechtler 1831-1850)
Pioneer Gold Maker Set (1830-1861)
North Carolina Gold Basic Set (Bechtler 1831-1850)
* This information is being provided by PCGS and you are encouraged to review the Important Information for each of these items: PCGS Population [View]; PCGS Price Guide [View]; Auction Prices Realized [View].  The PCGS population report, historic compilation of coin prices and auction prices are proprietary to Collectors Universe and remains the property of Collectors Universe.  It is available for personal use to Collectors Corner subscribers only.  Reproduction in any format is strictly prohibited, as is sharing of this import (or any data contained herein).  Also, errors and omissions can occur and accordingly, viewer should recognize these facts and that this information should not be the only source consulted when making a decision about buying or selling coins.

(click for full-size image)

(click for full-size image)