Collectors Corner^SM: The Collectibles Marketplace

The Proof 1974-S Eisenhower Dollar is one of five different issues produced under the 1974 Ike Dollar banner. Click image to enlarge.

The Eisenhower Dollar series was issued for only eight years, from 1971 through 1978, and at first blush every single issue in the series looks about as common as the next. That could certainly be said of the 1974 Ike Dollars, struck midway through the series to the tune of nearly 80 million – counting all iterations of the date.

There were 1974 copper-nickel clad strikes at the Philadelphia and Denver Mints, a cupronickel proof from San Francisco, and then there were two types of 40% silver Ikes, including an uncirculated and proof offering from the “S” Mint. Even many collectors who embrace numismatic modernity may take the 1974 Eisenhower Dollar as representing little more than a few holes to fill in a PCGS Registry Set. But that’s where beauty – and opportunity – await for the collector who looks a little deeper.

The 1974 Eisenhower Dollar marked a period in the series when it was clear to U.S. Mint officials that the series hadn’t lived up to its potential as a circulating coin. Few were using Ike Dollars for ordinary transactions in the mid-1970s, even though inflation was rendering a dollar coin theoretically much more relevant for use in vending machines, at diners and post offices, and other places where small change was rendered economically obsolete to wholly pay for transactions.

Following much fanfare upon its release in 1971, the Ike Dollar saw one more great hurrah in 1975 and 1976 when they were struck in huge quantities bearing a Bicentennial design for the nation’s 200th birthday. But by 1977 the U.S. government was already preparing to strike a mini dollar that a consulting firm believed would be better embraced by Americans than the large-size Ike Dollar had been.

The 1974 Eisenhower Dollar was emitted by the U.S. Mint in large enough numbers to fulfill needs for the large-size dollar coin in the Nevada casino circuit as well as to supply commerce with the small number of new dollars it needed for its negligible circulation demands. And while the coin is common in the absolute sense, there are some rabbit holes worth exploring that suggest this coin isn’t common in every sense of the word.

Most notably, it’s well known at least among Eisenhower Dollar aficionados that virtually every date in the series is conditionally scarce in grades of MS65. The coin is even more so challenging in MS66 or better grades. Prices easily reach into the hundreds and thousands of dollars for the best pieces. That’s most certainly the case with the 1974 and 1974-D clad business strikes; The 1974 Philadelphia strike approaches $300 in MS66 while the 1974-D is no slouch with a price tag exceeding $100 in MS66. The top grade known among PCGS-graded examples of the 1974 clad Ikes is MS67, where the 1974 is worth a whopping $18,500; the 1974-D Ike tops out in a grade of MS67+, representing a $6,500 purchase.

The numismatic strikes are also enticing, not just for their sheer novelty as proof-strike and 40% silver offerings, but also as bona fide scarcities – at the right grade anyway. A 1974-S clad proof goes for $6,000 in PR70DCAM, while the 1974-S silver dollar garners $600 in that same grade. Finally, a 1974-S Mint State strike is known as high as MS69, an example of which would set back the Ike collector by an astonishing $11,500.